Exclude from reset ignored for 0-0 controls

Question

MIDI Target Manufacturer(s): Original, Generic

I have a bunch of buttons that select presets by a controller number. Typically this will be in  the form: CC20, Value 9/9, Send On Only.

They work fine. I have set them also to be excluded from a reset. But on a reset *all* of these buttons are sending out their data! You can imagine the receiving device goes nuts!

However, if I set the values to 0/9 (not that it matters in reality with a 'Send On Only', everything works as it should.

A bug, or something I'm not understanding?

Images

PNG image (5).png

Comments

That sure sounds like a bug. I’ll try to confirm it soon. Thanks for reporting. By the way, are you on the beta program? Can I add you? Thanks!

---

Thank you. Sorry to be turning up so any little bugs in short order!

---

this one and note-on-on -- though we haven't solved them yet -- are theoretically easy oversights in code. Glad to have the reports and to fix. Thanks!

---

what's a "reset" mean here? thanks.

---

It's a standard MD Subtype 'Reset to Defaults' button. When I say 'on  a reset' in my description above I mean pressing this button.

---

Okay but you have a workaround by just setting min and max differently, or no?

---

Yes. If I set the values to 0/9 the problem goes away. As I said, this isn't a huge problem, but it may help to track down other On/On bugs.

---

Thanks noted. Please note that the NoteOnOn issue -- not this issue -- is fixed in latest beta.

---

That’s good. Thanks. I will await the full release before I test removing my StreamByter kludge.